Ahh, okay! Didn't realize individual encounters didn't stack. Could I use the December lights to grant it? Or another possibility, which is something I'd been kicking around before I left: if Aaron wrote his number on it in dry-erase pen and used it to connect to the Network (as a joke, because lol, look, now it's a crystal ball), would seeing images in it be enough of a canon recurrence to grant the item Echo?

And I have a second Echo request: if tier 2 Echoes work the same way I remember them, I'd like to request this.

Reason for Echo: Giving Julien the cloak-pin of the Dunedain in case Aaron loses his echoes again, a significant Moment of Jewelry Giving meant to be a gesture of solidarity between Aaron, who is human and might lose his Echoes, and Julien, who is like 75% pigeon at this point and who has kept his echoes. It's meant to bridge a distance, and that's what the ring of Barahir is all about. He gave it to Arwen, and in ages past it was given to Barahir by Elves in token of friendship.
Type and tier: Tier 2, item + memory
What is returned: The ring of Barahir + general knowledge of its significance as a token of friendship between Men and Elves -- he'll know it was given to a man named Barahir in ages past, and know that he gave it to an Elf, but remember nothing specific about that Elf.

Thanks for working with me on this! I appreciate the help, I am so rusty at this game's mechanics ♥